Skip to main content
site map
rss feedemail usour twitterour facebook page pintrest
Latest Posts

Blogging By the Sea
Saturday, April 22 2017

April Round Robin topic is suggested by Victoria Chatham: Reviews. Love 'em, hate 'em or totally ignore them. Amazon tells us the more 4 or 5 reviews the merrier, but how to get them?

To review or not to review – that is the question! I find it odd when another writer tells me they never read reviews. Really? I always read them. Maybe not ALL of them but I do read them for a lot of reasons.

As a reader, I read reviews to get an idea if this is a book I really want to spend my time and money on. One thing that really irks me in this day of self publishing is authors who throw the book out there thinking grammar and spell check is good enough and fail to get the book properly edited. Maybe if I wasn’t a writer myself it wouldn’t bother me so much but a book full of misspellings and improper grammar drives me nuts and I can’t get past it. So a couple reviews that mention this problem is a definite NO for me to bother downloading. But other comments about the type of story, the depth of characters, or even just a description of characters might make up my mind for me. For instance, I love stories about military people, but hate stories about millionaires and beauty queens. I grabbed up a book on sale that happened to be set in the area I grew up in – just because I knew all the places and it sounded fun. Turned out to be a fantastic book and I can’t wait for the next one by this new author.

As an author, I read my own reviews. Partly because patting myself on the back requires uncomfortable contortions, but more because I learn from the reviews. If I let myself be open about the critical comments it can only help me grow as an author to avoid those pitfalls in my future books. Likewise, when reviewer after reviewer has the same or similar positive comments, I know what I’m getting right. I don’t write books for the benefit of critiquers and editors, but for my readers and reading my reviews helps me to know and understand what my readers liked and didn’t like and work harder to meet their expectations with each new book I write.

As for GETTING reviews – that’s the tough question. I’ve had readers who write me gushing emails telling me how much they loved my book, but when I ask for a review tell me they don’t know how to write one. I’ve been known to suggest they copy and past the email they just sent. I have four kids who love my stories, three of them daughters who read the kind of books I write anyway. But one of them says she just “doesn’t do reviews!” Not even for good old MOM! I’ve run contests offering a drawing from all the names who write me a review. I always ask for a review when someone tells me they loved my book. One other thing I did was to create a bookmarker with my logo on it and the comment that if they enjoyed this book please consider writing me a review. I put one in every print version of my book that I sell, both at book signings and in books on consignment at local bookstores. I slip them into books at B&N for the length of time my books show up on their shelves as well.  But on the whole I find trying to get reviews is difficult. Now I’m going to check out all the other visits to this Round Robin blog to see what other ideas I can try.

Marci Baun  
Dr. Bob Rich 
Beverley Bateman 

Helena Fairfax 
Rachael Kosinski 
A.J. Maguire  
Margaret Fieland 
Connie Vines 
Rhobin Courtright 

Posted by: Skye Taylor AT 12:01 am   |  Permalink   |  6 Comments  |  Email
Enjoyed your post, especially your view on critical reviews. With the number of books hitting the market every month it is increasingly hard to get reviews, but your suggestions should help.
Posted by Rhobin on 04/22/2017 - 12:13 PM
Skye, I particularly relate to learning from your reviewers. I encourage this kind of feedback by seeking beta readers before I release a book. Next time someone claims not to know how to write a review, point them to :) Bob
Posted by Bob Rich on 04/22/2017 - 08:00 PM
Skye, the bookmark idea is a really good idea! I know in my latest ebook, my editors put little notes in the back saying how you can help review/learn more about my books, which I thought was an incredible step forward. But yes, reviews are very hard to find! It needs to become more mainstream, I feel.
Posted by Rachael Kosinski on 04/23/2017 - 10:25 AM
I love the idea of the bookmark, Skye. I've always been very reticent about asking for reviews, but now I do try and ask people. I'm always very grateful if they take the time to review. I enjoyed your post, especially about taking on board the negative reviews.
Posted by Helena Fairfax on 04/23/2017 - 11:57 AM
Reviews can be really hard to get. None of my family reads the genre I write. Well, my mom read my title The Whispering House, but she's not very internet savvy. I appreciate that she enjoyed it, so I'll have to settle for a personal review. LOL The bookmark is a great idea. I'll include it in my next book. :)
Posted by Marci Baun on 04/24/2017 - 08:05 PM
Good post. I agree about editing. I always get mine edited and I get critiques to help improve a book. You mention how hard it is to get a review and I agree. I don't usually bother because of the time, effort and limited results, but I may try a couple of your ideas. Thanks, Skye.
Posted by Beverley Bateman on 04/26/2017 - 02:34 PM

Post comment
Email Address

(max 750 characters)
* Required Fields
Note: All comments are subject to approval. Your comment will not appear until it has been approved.

    Site Mailing List  Sign Guest Book  View Guest Book 

    Skye Taylor
    St Augustine, Florida

    Site Powered By
        Online web site design